Wishup vs Get Magic Virtual Assistants: Who Is More Reliable?
Not sure if Wishup or Get Magic is the better choice? We break down pricing, expertise, and real user experiences so you can hire the right virtual executive assistant from the right company.
Are you a busy business owner who thinks a long to-do list is a badge of honor?
Let’s do some quick math.
If you spend 3 hours a day on admin tasks like emails, scheduling, and follow-ups, it equates to 15 hours a week or 780 hours a year. That’s nearly one month of non-stop admin work.
Imagine what you could do with that time? Closing deals, strategizing growth, or, dare we say, actually taking a break?
A great virtual assistant (VA) gets your routine admin tasks done, stays on their toes, and gives you back your valuable time.
Both Wishup and Get Magic virtual executive assistants are hired by busy founders. But which one truly helps you scale? Let’s compare.
Get Magic vs Wishup: A Quick Comparison
Before diving into the details, here’s a quick glimpse at both Wishup and Get Magic virtual assistants.
Wishup - The Get Magic Alternative with Risk-Free Virtual Assistants
- 50+ industries served, including healthcare, real estate, and e-commerce.
- Collaborated with 900+ global founders in 2025.
- Saved 850000+ hours for busy business owners.
- 1500+ pre-vetted virtual assistants to choose from.
- 99% reliability rate in meeting deadlines.
- Top 0.1% talent that’s always ready to start.
- 2000+ tasks managed monthly.
- 98.8% client satisfaction rate.
Wishup’s virtual assistants gave these founders back their focus. Here’s how they review their work:
Hiring Speed of Virtual Executive Assistants
If your business needs help, you shouldn’t have to wait weeks to get it. Let’s see which service, Wishup or Magic, gets you a virtual assistant faster.
Wishup: Hire Your Virtual Assistant in 60 Minutes
Easily onboard a pre-trained and triple-vetted executive assistant in just 60 minutes (yes, really!). Wishup’s virtual executive assistants come with a minimum of 3-5 years of experience. Just hire from 200+ trained virtual assistants in an hour, start delegating, and get going.
Get Magic: Hire in 3 Days (72 Hours)
Get Magic has a delayed hiring process that could take up to 72 hours (3 days). While it’s faster than traditional hiring, it’s still not as instant as Wishup’s 60-minute onboarding.
Verdict: Need a virtual executive assistant yesterday? Wishup has you covered in 60 minutes.
Hiring Standards – Do They Offer High-Caliber Virtual Assistants?
Beyond being a proactive VA, they will be the reason you stay ahead without burning out.
Wishup: The Top 0.1% of Virtual Assistants
Wishup follows a hyper-focused six-level vetting process. This is performed to ensure that only the top 0.1% make it through. Every assistant has a minimum of 3-5 years of experience and is pre-trained before being assigned to clients.
Get Magic Assistants Quality: The Top 0.5% of Applicants
Magic pre-vets its virtual executive assistants and selects from the top 0.5% of applicants. However, details about the vetting process or levels of screening remain unclear.
Verdict: Wishup’s extreme vetting ensures elite-quality (0.1%) virtual assistants from day one.
AI Skills - Are the Virtual Assistants Trained in AI Tools?
In 2025, hiring a virtual assistant without tech skills (especially AI) will not get you far.
Wishup: AI & No-Code Experts (120+ Tools Pre-Trained)
Imagine this: You hire a VA to automate your workflows, but they’ve never used Zapier. Or you ask them to create reports, and they fumble with QuickBooks. Now you’re the one training them. Wasn’t that exactly what you were trying to avoid?
That won’t happen with Wishup.
Wishup’s virtual assistants come pre-trained in 50+ AI tools and 70+ no-code platforms, so they hit the ground running. Some of the tools they’re already familiar with are ChatGPT (for smarter content & communication), Zapier (to automate boring, repetitive tasks), QuickBooks (so your finances stay sorted), Trello & Slack (for seamless project management), and a lot more.
And that’s just the beginning.
Before they ever start working with you, Wishup puts them through a one-month structured training to ensure they’re proficient with these tools.
Get Magic: AI-Powered Platform, But No Clear Training Details
Magic assistants work through a centralized platform called Magic AI. It sounds impressive but here’s the catch: we don’t know how many AI tools they actually know.
Also, it’s unclear if they’re already skilled in automation or learning on the job.
So, while Magic AI might make their work smoother, you could still end up training them on specific tools if they’re not already familiar.
Verdict: Wishup delivers AI and no-code specialists (trained on 120+ tools) ready to scale your business faster. Get Magic’s AI platform helps, but the depth of its assistants’ tech knowledge is very much uncertain.
Pricing - Who Is Affordable?
Let’s talk numbers. Because as much as we all want to enjoy great service, we also want to make sure we’re not paying top dollar for something that’s not the right fit, right?
Wishup: Affordable Pricing (From $9.99/Hour)
If you need help with administrative tasks while keeping your budget in check, that’s where Wishup shines. With pricing starting at just $9.99/hour, you can hire a top-tier, pre-trained virtual assistant without breaking the bank.
The monthly plans (billed monthly) are as follows:
- Kickstart Plan (4 hours/day) – Starts from $999/month.
- Growth Engine Plan (8 hours/day) – Starts from $1,799/month.
No hidden fees. No surprise charges. You know exactly what you’re paying for, and that’s it. Plus, these executive assistants aren’t just “good enough.” They’re the top 0.1% of VAs, trained in over 120 tools, ready to get straight to work.
Get Magic Virtual Assistant Pricing: $15/Hour (LATEST)
The pricing of Magic assistants starts at $15/hour, and the service is billed weekly. If you go with Get Magic’s standard pricing, it costs $600/week and $2,400/month. That’s 2.5x more expensive than Wishup for the same amount of time and quality. Also, for tasks outside your Magic assistant’s working hours, the pricing is $35 per hour after the first free 20 hours.
The flexibility might seem nice, but when you look at the cost difference, you might start to wonder if you’re paying for something that’s really worth it.
But if you’re okay with spending significantly more for a flexible, hourly arrangement that doesn’t always guarantee the same quality of training and tools? Well, Get Magic might still work for you.
Verdict: Wishup gives you premium talent at startup-friendly rates. Get Magic offers flexible weekly billing, but at a significantly higher cost.
Magic Virtual Assistant Pricing Calculator:
Magic assistants cost $31,200 per year. Onboarding them saves you more money than hiring a full-time employee, but the annual savings from Wishup go up to 83.81% more than Magic’s virtual assistants for the same quality. Refer to the table below for detailed VA pricing and saving calculations.
*Full-time employee cost based on median salary for similar roles in the US, plus a 30% overhead per employee.
Wishup saves you serious money. With up to 83.81% more savings, you’re getting top-tier virtual assistance without burning a hole in your budget. If maximizing ROI is the goal, Wishup is the clear winner.
Service Coverage - Wishup vs Get Magic
When you look for a virtual executive assistant, you want someone who understands your business. You don't want a jack-of-all-trades who’s great at admin tasks but doesn’t know the first thing about your specific industry, right? Let’s find out how Wishup and Get Magic fare when it comes to service coverage.
Wishup: Broad Expertise Across 50+ Sectors
If you’re running a growing e-commerce business, you might need help with customer support, product listings, or social media management. Or maybe you're in the healthcare sector, needing assistance with appointment scheduling or handling patient inquiries. What if you're in real estate, looking for someone to help with property research and client communications?
You’re probably thinking, “Where do I even start looking for someone who can handle all that?”
Here’s where Wishup comes to the rescue. Wishup virtual assistants have experience in 50+ industries, meaning they’ve already worked in fields like real estate, healthcare, e-commerce, startups, and more. They know what to do and how to do it in your niche. They are familiar with the challenges you faced. No more long onboarding processes trying to explain your specific needs. You’re getting someone who can dive right in.
Get Magic Assistants: Generalized Admin Services
Magic assistants handle executive, admin, customer service, and bookkeeping tasks in your business. They also help in achieving your personal goals. However, there’s no clear mention of industry-based experience. Wishup provides executive assistants with a niche skillset across 50+ industries.
Verdict: Get Magic covers standard business tasks but lacks clear industry-specific support, which could feel like a gamble. Wishup provides tailored talent across 50+ industries.
- Wishup vs Athena Executive Assistants - Which is better?
- Wishup vs Belay - Which is the founders' best choice?
- Wishup vs Boldly - Which is the better executive assistant service?
- Do you need a personal assistant or an executive assistant?
- What does a virtual assistant do? A detailed guide for 2025.
Talent Pool - Where Does Your Virtual Assistant Come From?
The location of your executive assistants is going to impact their work, communication, or understanding of your business. Let’s compare where Wishup and Get Magic source their talent from.
Wishup: India & USA - Two World-Class Talent Pools
Wishup has a clever mix of talent from two powerhouses: India and the USA.
India: A country that strives on STEM (technical expertise) and cost-effectiveness. If you need someone to handle data analysis, automation, or routine admin tasks with accuracy, the executive assistants from India are likely to hit the ground running.
USA: US-based executive assistants from Wishup are game-changers if you’re running a business where client communication is key, and you need someone who understands the American culture, time zones, and business etiquette.
Wishup has you covered with the best of both worlds!
Get Magic: Philippines & Latin America Talent
Get Magic taps into talented professionals from the Philippines and Latin America. They are emerging markets for outsourcing. However, countries like the Philippines and certain parts of Latin America can be affected by climate issues or natural calamities more frequently, which can occasionally disrupt work or cause delays.
On top of that, while these regions are strong in customer service and general admin, they’re not as well-known for excelling in STEM fields (science, technology, engineering, and math). So, if you’re looking for technical expertise or specialized support, Wishup’s team, with its extensive pool of experts in both technical and business roles, might have the edge.
Verdict: Get Magic offers cheap support, but for more technical depth and reliability, Wishup’s talent pools in India and the USA might be a better fit.
Workforce Management - Tracking Your Virtual Assistants
Let’s take a look at how each one helps you keep track of your tasks and stay on top of things without the stress.
Wishup: Free Real-Time Virtual Assistant Management App ($299 Value Included)
Wishup provides a free real-time mobile app (normally worth $299) that lets you easily track tasks, get end-of-day reports, and give feedback instantly. Imagine being able to just open an app and see exactly what your virtual assistant has accomplished during the day.
You can even chat, assign new tasks, or check on progress, all from the palm of your hand. It’s perfect for those days when you’re juggling a ton of things and need to quickly check in on your assistant without feeling like you’re constantly micromanaging.
Get Magic: Task Management Software
Get Magic has a task management software. However, while it’s designed to keep your executive assistant organized and on top of their duties, the specifics on mobile access and how you interact with the system are a bit undefined. It’s not totally clear if you can get the same real-time tracking or quick updates like you can with Wishup’s app.
Verdict: Wishup offers a much better, feature-packed, user-friendly executive assistant management app (both Android and iOS).
Risk-Free Hiring - Who Has Your Back During Tough Times?
Wishup: Zero-Risk Trial & Instant Replacements
Wishup offers a 3-day free trial.
That should probably make you breathe a sigh of relief!
Yup, no commitments, no fine print. You get a chance to see if the virtual assistant fits your needs without shelling out a single penny.
And if for any reason things don’t click, Wishup doesn’t make you wait forever. You can get an instant replacement. No back-and-forth, no long notice periods. You get what you need, fast. Too good to believe, right?
Get Magic Assistant Replacement Policy: Potentially 5-7 Working Days
If your Magic virtual executive assistant isn’t working out, you will be asked to send an email stating the problem. Finding a replacement - a better assistant - is expected to take around 7 working days. This happens after scheduling another round of interviews, which consumes more time from your busy life. But Wishup provides instant replacements the moment you ask without any hassle.
Verdict: Wishup ensures easy, no-questions-asked replacements. Get Magic offers flexible cancellation but lacks a defined replacement policy.
Final Verdict: Which Virtual Assistant Should You Hire? Get Magic or Wishup?
If you want a well-established service with a wide talent pool, flexible pricing, and a risk-free trial, Wishup is your go-to. On the other hand, if you like a more flexible billing system and are okay with a bit of uncertainty in terms of replacement policies, Get Magic might be worth considering.
Have you made your decision?
👉 Book a Free Consultation Today and hire your virtual assistant in just 60 minutes from Wishup!
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a magic executive assistant?
A magic executive assistant is a trained professional from either the Philippines or Latin America who handles the administrative tasks of your business by working remotely. The cost of hiring a magic executive assistant starts from $15 per hour.
How much does a magic virtual assistant cost in 2025?
The latest cost of hiring a magic assistant is $15 per hour in 2025. For outside your assistant's regular hours, you can use Magic 24/7, which costs $35 per hour (after the free 20 hours) to get your work done by a team of executive assistants who work 24x7. But Wishup assistants' cost starts from just $9.99/hour, delivering better value as they are trained on 120+ AI tools.
What is Magic assistant pricing per month?
If you're hiring a Magic executive assistant at $15 per hour and working full-time (8 hours a day) on a typical month with 31 days, you'd be paying for around 23 working days (excluding weekends). That adds up to $2,760 per month (which is significantly higher than many other EA services offering flat-rate pricing). For the same quality and risk-free replacements, you can hire pre-trained Wishup executive assistants for just $999 per month.
What is Magic assistant pricing per hour?
The Magic assistant pricing per hour is $15. But when you need support after the working hours of your Magic executive assistant, the cost goes upto $35 per hour with Magic 24/7 (after the initial free 20 hours).